|
Q: Chiropractic Treatment and Mood Disorders
Is there any research supporting chiropractic treatments to restore
chemical imbalances resulting in mood disorders(bipolar,etc.)?
Dear Debra --
None that I am aware of. I'd be interested in hearing from any reader
who knows of any -- as long as the treatment has been tested against a control
"placebo" treatment. That kind of research is difficult to do,
so we don't see much of it. By contrast, "case reports" are
easy to generate, so you might find all sorts of reports that this or that
"works" for somebody. What we're looking for is something that
clearly works better than the suggestion that something is going to help --
because just that suggestion, especially when it comes along with a good
ritual like an office and a procedure and a charge, can help a lot of people,
at least for a while. In most research studies of depression, the
"placebo" group gets better in about 25-30% of cases. What you
want is something that works better than that. That's hard to
demonstrate even if there really is something out there that "works"
-- look at the www.truehope.com site for
example. They're getting pretty close to showing something, but until
their "controlled trial" begun last July is released, and shows the
nutritional supplement works better than placebo, I'm going to hold off
recommending it to patients (unless they've tried all sorts of other stuff and
are pretty desperate, as has been the case for about 5 of my patients, one of
whom did try it).
Dr. Phelps
Published May, 2001
|