|
Q: Comparison of BP & Cycloid?
My psychiatrist keeps changing my diagnosis. So far, he's considered
bipolar disorder (which I accept), then borderline personality disorder (I ran
the DSM IV criteria past friends, colleagues & relatives & told my
psychiatrist I couldn't find anyone who thought I fitted the
description)reactive depression (which doesn't seem to account for the mania)
& now cycloid psychosis. I'm struggling to find out what the
difference is. Both bipolar and cycloid seem to be about cyclical
depression/mania & psychosis. Can you point me in the direction of any
comparison between bipolar and cycloid diagnoses?
Thanks
Dear Ms. P' --
I hope might have found my little essay on BPII
vs. Borderline PD, or will find it useful if you haven't read it yet.
It might be on target. "Cycloid" is either a term used outside
the US somewhere(see addendum below), or a jargon term that's not really a diagnosis in the official
terminology of at least US psychiatrists -- so I don't think you'll find the
comparison you're looking for. More details on the diagnosis and
subtleties can be found in the diagnosis and diagnosis details sections of my website
on BPII.
Dr. Phelps
Addendum: a grad student studying these name-games for
an exam kindly wrote to direct me further on "cycloid" -- it's in the
International Classification of Diseases (ICD) terminology not routinely used in
the U.S. Here's a link for anyone who runs into this issue on cycloid
states. I think you'll find it illustrates nicely the mess of terms
out there. The bottom line is that the essay to which I referred the Ms.
P' does indeed apply. However, it's nice to have folks out there keeping
me on my toes!
JP 2/8/2001
Published November, 2001
|