|
Q: Paxil Studies? Link to Mania or BP?
I have read a lot on message board, on this site and others, about
people diagnosed with depression and taking Paxil, having their illness morph
(for lack of a better word) into a psychotic manic episode resulting in a
bi-polar diagnosis.
I also have a very good friend who has recently suffered from this scenario.
He has been on anti-depressants for years. He started taking Paxil
about a year and a half ago. For the first time, at age 29, he had a
severe manic episode (that he is still in) and spent two weeks in the hospital.
Have there been any studies done on Paxil? Have they shown any link to
mania or resulting in bi-polar disorder? Where can I find information on
this topic?
Thanks for your help.
Dear Kim
You can find a summary of the problem with antidepressants inducing mania in a
book by a Harvard professor named Joseph Glenmullen entitled Prozac
Backlash. It's a bit overstated in most chapters, but the actual
information he provides (as opposed to how he provides it) is enough to make
people slow down in their enthusiasm for antidepressants generally. The
problem you clearly understand regarding Paxil holds true for nearly all
antidepressants; Prozac may be a bit worse, actually. The worst part of
the story, and the reason why I refer you to Glenmullen, is that the
manufacturers of the medications, or at least Eli Lilly who makes Prozac, are
well aware of these risks and have taken systematic steps to keep the public
from being sufficiently aware as to practically evaluate the risks of taking an
antidepressant, for anyone.
For more on the controversy regarding the use of
antidepressants in bipolar disorder, when a person is known to have that
illness, see this summary.
Dr. Phelps
|